Home Politics Opinion Freedom of speech in Israel – a threat to life and limb?

Freedom of speech in Israel – a threat to life and limb?

A selfie by Rachel Goldenberg. CC BY-SA 4.0, date taken: 13 January 2021

Berlin, Germany (Weltexpress). On an Israeli breakfast television programme, actress Chelli Goldenberg criticised Netanyahu’s war – believing the programme was on a commercial break. A presenter warned against “dangerous words”. Her comments subsequently triggered insults and threats.

On 26 October 2026, one day before the Israeli parliamentary elections, the Israeli actress Chelli Goldenberg was a guest on the morning programme Opening the Day (Hebrew: “Potechim Yom”) on the private broadcaster Channel 13. The presenters were Elad Zohar and Yarden Harel. The conversation was originally intended to focus on her career and the 72-year-old’s new film.

During the conversation, Goldenberg stated that she was “no longer proud to be Israeli”. One of the programme’s presenters immediately interrupted and warned: “Those are dangerous words that should not be said on air.” Nevertheless, Goldenberg continued her remarks and criticised the actions of the Israeli military and the brutal settlers in the Palestinian territories occupied since the Six-Day War in 1967. She described this as the “sin of occupation” and said that everything currently happening was a consequence of it. As examples, she cited growing religious fanaticism and its influence on politics. She condemned “Jewish terror” and the arrogance of the settlers. Furthermore, she argued that an oppressed minority (meaning the Palestinians) had the right to fight for their freedom.

The presenters disagreed and referred, amongst other things, to the Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and to the Hamas attack on 7 October 2023. In this context, Goldenberg emphasised that she was a great patriot and loved the country. She compared her disappointment to the feeling of a parent whose child is developing differently than expected. She also mentioned that, following 7 October 2023, she had regularly helped out with a volunteer group in the kibbutzim of Nir Oz, Nahal Oz and Be’eri, which had been affected by the attacks.

It was only later in the conversation that Chelli Goldenberg realised – reportedly “horrified” – that she was live on air. She reacted with visible shock and explained that she had thought the conversation was taking place during a commercial break. She said the presenters had not informed her that they were back on air, and announced her intention to end the discussion. The programme then went into a commercial break.

Later, when the programme resumed, Goldenberg apologised to viewers for the harshness and intensity of her words. She described herself as an impulsive person who speaks with great passion, and explained that she had expressed her opinions more strongly than she normally would have. She said the drama and harshness of her words had been exaggerated. However, she continued to stand by the substance of her statements!

As expected, a video clip from the programme went viral, both on social media in Israel and internationally. A barrage of insults and threats from the community of genocide supporters rained down on her – primarily because of her implicit justification of the Hamas attack on 7 October 2023. Others, by contrast, praised Goldenberg for openly expressing her views – something that has become a rarity even in Israel, as suggested by the warning issued by one of the programme’s presenters.

What, then, does ‘freedom of speech’ actually mean as a supposedly important pillar of the much-vaunted ‘Western community of values’, of which Israel is also considered a part? But in Israel, it is no different from elsewhere in the ‘liberal’ West. You can still say what you think quietly and in private, but if you do so publicly, then the truth becomes ‘dangerous’! So much for a community of values!

Previous articleDawn in the Cosmos – The Rassvet Project Takes Shape
Next articleNvidia announces change in leadership, Huang resigns

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

sixty eight − = 67